Managing an evidence room isn’t just about keeping shelves in order—it’s about safeguarding every single case that passes through your agency doors. But let’s be honest—evidence room management isn’t exactly glamorous. It’s a behind-the-scenes job that is often underfunded, misunderstood, and under immense pressure.
Between ever-growing caseloads, limited space, unclear policies, and constant interruptions from detectives and attorneys needing that “one thing real quick”, it’s no wonder the system breaks down. But with the right strategies, you can build a more organized, efficient, and less stressful environment—for your team and for yourself.
Before diving into this blog post, be sure to watch the latest episode of Forensics Unfiltered! We sat down with the dynamic duo—Kelly O’Donnell and Danielle Wamstad from Evidence Solutions Inc.—to unpack the most common pitfalls in evidence room management and, more importantly, how to fix them. Once you’ve watched, scroll down for a deep dive into everything we discussed—plus practical, actionable steps to make your evidence room more efficient, more compliant, and way less stressful.
APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY | CASTBOX
Why Evidence Room Management Matters More Than Ever
Evidence rooms are the backbone of forensic integrity. If you’re an evidence technician, supervisor, or forensic unit leader, you know the pressure: chain of custody accuracy, efficient intake and release procedures, managing audits, and keeping up with evolving policies.
This is your comprehensive guide to smarter, more sustainable evidence room management. We’ll cover:
- How to spot and fix inefficiencies in your current systems
- Strategies to lead your evidence team with clarity and confidence
- Real-world examples of how small changes lead to big impacts
Let’s talk shop—and fix what’s not working.
When the Evidence Room Becomes a Bottleneck
Whether it’s backlog, bad communication, or too many cooks in the chain-of-custody kitchen, evidence rooms are often the most overlooked—and most overburdened—units in a forensic lab or law enforcement agency.
Common Challenges in Evidence Rooms
- Lack of standardized intake procedures
- Poor physical organization or limited space
- No tracking for special requests from detectives or attorneys
- Audit stress due to outdated systems
If your evidence room feels more chaotic than controlled, you’re not alone.
Most issues aren’t about people. They’re about unclear systems.
The good news? You can fix the system.
Start with Systems: Fixing Evidence Room Organization
Strong evidence room organization doesn’t just help your evidence technicians—it protects your cases, your agency, and your reputation. Start by reviewing what’s already in place.
1. Conduct a Process Audit
Ask these key questions:
- How is evidence being submitted?
- Who has access—and when?
- Are chain-of-custody forms being completed correctly and consistently?
- Where are the bottlenecks?
Have an outside person walk through your evidence room workflow from intake to release. Sometimes fresh eyes catch gaps you’ve missed.
2. Assign Clear Roles (and Backups!)
In smaller agencies, evidence management can fall on one person. But what happens when they’re out?
Assign clear responsibilities and designate backups who are cross-trained. Use simple flowcharts to document who handles what.
Pro tip: Create a visual organizational chart specific to evidence processes—not just staff hierarchy.
3. Upgrade to Smart Tracking Tools
Barcode systems, evidence management software, and digital logs reduce human error. Even simple tools like shared dashboards or task boards can keep everyone in sync.
If you’re still using paper logs or Excel, it’s time to upgrade.
4. Keep Aiming for a 1:1 Ratio
One simple principle that can transform your evidence room? The 1:1 rule: for every item that comes in, aim to remove one.
While it won’t always be perfectly possible, this mindset helps prevent backlog before it starts. The real problem in many evidence rooms isn’t lack of space—it’s that nothing ever leaves.
Regular purging keeps things manageable and audit-ready. If your team needs help building a confident and compliant process for disposal, check out our eCourse: Evidence Destruction 101: Build Confidence with the Evidence Purging Process Using our Systematic Approach.
Supervising Your Evidence Technician Team: What Works
Leadership in an evidence room requires more than knowing policies—it’s about people. Here’s how to create a work environment that minimizes burnout and maximizes accuracy.
5. Don’t Ignore the Front Desk Pressure
Evidence techs are often interrupted by detectives, prosecutors, or citizens making “urgent” requests. This constant task-switching destroys focus and increases the risk of mistakes.
Leadership Tip:
- Create a written request process for evidence pulls
- Establish reasonable turnaround expectations
- Train command staff and detectives on evidence room protocols
6. Normalize Talking About Workload
Your evidence techs may not always say when they’re overwhelmed, but their work will reflect it.
Use weekly check-ins to:
- Review tasks in progress
- Adjust assignments based on caseload
- Flag recurring workflow issues
These conversations help uncover systemic problems before they explode during an audit.
7. Model Calm in a Storm
Whether it’s a high-profile case or last-minute audit, your staff takes emotional cues from you. If you’re stressed, they’ll be stressed.
Instead, model:
- Clear priorities
- Realistic expectations
- Trust in your people’s training and judgment
Fixing the Gray Areas: Policy, Access & Boundaries
Not all challenges are technical. Many are interpersonal or political.
8. Address Unauthorized Access Early
A detective walking into the evidence room without logging access may not sound like a big deal—until something goes missing.
- Lock the room.
- Post policies clearly.
- Follow through consistently.
You don’t need to start a fight. Just start enforcing the rules.
9. Review Your Evidence Room Policy Annually
Evidence rooms are high-risk areas. Your policy should include:
- Who can access the room (and under what conditions)
- Chain-of-custody documentation requirements
- Intake, storage, and release procedures
- Audit protocols
Need help drafting or revising your SOP? Our Forensic SOP Crash Course walks you through it.
When It’s Time to Ask for Help
Sometimes your team is doing everything right—but the workload is simply too high.
10. Advocate Upward with Data
Leadership listens to numbers. When making a case for new hires or updated tech, show:
- Monthly intake and release numbers
- Evidence room audit results
- Error rates before and after specific changes
Keep it factual, not emotional. You’re not complaining—you’re showing the cost of doing nothing.
11. Get Peer Input
Don’t reinvent the wheel. Connect with other agencies and forensic supervisors to:
- Benchmark best practices
- Share policy templates
- Ask about tools they love (or hate)
Our podcast episode dives into real examples of what’s working—and what’s not—in evidence room management.
Final Thoughts: Evidence Room Management is a Leadership Skill
Leading an evidence room means navigating policies, people, and pressure—all at once. But you’re not alone.
Key Reminders:
- Clarity creates calm. Fix systems before fixing people.
- Documentation is protection. For you, your team, and your cases.
- Leadership is about standards AND support. Your staff should feel trusted, respected, and equipped.
Next Steps for Stronger Evidence Room Management
- 🎧 Watch the full podcast episode to see these strategies in action
- Take the next step with our eCourse: Evidence Destruction 101 and build a confident, compliant system for purging evidence
- Get an expert’s perspective with the free 30-minute training from Evidence Solutions Inc: Audit/Inventory – Preparing Your Evidence Unit
Messy systems don’t fix themselves. But with smart changes and strong leadership, your evidence room can go from stressor to streamlined. You’ve got the tools, now it’s time to use them!
🎙 Subscribe now on your favorite podcast platform and never miss an episode!
We’d also love to welcome you into our private community of forensic professionals for support, shared experiences, and valuable resources. Get the help you need from others who truly understand what you’re going through. Click here to join now!
