Let’s get real: the expectations placed on forensic professionals today are higher than ever. Whether you’re a crime scene investigator, latent print examiner, or a newly promoted forensic supervisor, there’s one thing that can either make or break the integrity of your work—your documentation.
And we’re not just talking about checking boxes or writing long reports. We’re talking about defensible, reproducible, scientifically sound documentation that holds up under scrutiny. That’s why having a clear understanding of forensic case report best practices is non-negotiable.
Forensic consultants, like our guest John Black from Black & White Forensics, are often brought in to examine that documentation with a fine tooth comb. And if they find gaps? Attorneys will use them.
So let’s explore exactly what consultants are looking for, what good documentation looks like, and how you can start improving yours today.
APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY | CASTBOX
What Forensic Consultants Look for in Case Documentation
When your report lands on a consultant’s desk, the evaluation doesn’t start with your conclusion. It starts with the quality of your documentation. Here are the top things forensic consultants look for:
1. Clear and Logical Decision-Making
- Are your conclusions supported with step-by-step logic?
- Can someone unfamiliar with the case understand how you got from A to B?
- Are conflicting data or limitations acknowledged?
2. Complete and High-Resolution Photographs
- Are your images of sufficient resolution for independent review?
- Is metadata intact or altered?
- Can the consultant see what you saw?
3. Transparent Processing Techniques
- Did you document the method used to collect or process the evidence?
- Were enhancement tools (like Photoshop) used, and if so, how?
- Are any edits clearly marked and reversible?
4. Use of Best Practices
- Are methods consistent with OSAC or other accepted bodies?
- Were procedures followed to reduce contextual bias?
5. Notes that Show Your Thinking
- Did you capture your observations and decisions in real-time?
- Did you document who did what, when, and how it progressed?
- Are changes or corrections explained?
“I’ve had cases where I tell the attorney, ‘There’s nothing to question here. The examiner did a fantastic job.’ And that’s exactly what you want a consultant to say.” — John Black
If your documentation checks all these boxes, you’re far more likely to withstand scrutiny—or avoid it altogether.
Common Documentation Pitfalls That Undermine Your Work
Not every report is consultant-proof. In fact, most aren’t. John shared several red flags that instantly raise questions:
Red Flags That Forensic Consultants Often Spot
- Missing or blurry photographs
- Lack of metadata or explanation of image properties
- Vague or generalized conclusions
- No documentation of conflicting findings or alternative explanations
- Notes that seem edited after the fact or added retroactively
These issues aren’t just technical missteps—they can create the perception of bias, sloppiness, or worse.
“Sometimes the documentation tells a totally different story than what the conclusion says.” — John Black
If you’re aiming for bulletproof documentation, start by addressing these weak spots.
Modernizing Your Forensic Documentation Practices: Technology Is Moving On… Are You?
Let’s talk about something no one wants to admit:
Too many forensic professionals are still documenting their work the way they were taught 15 or 20 years ago. Not because it’s best practice—just because it’s comfortable.
Sound familiar?
You’re not alone. But the truth is this: The science has changed. The expectations have changed. The legal climate has changed.
So your documentation must change, too.
“We’re required in this science to grow with the science,” John noted. “That means using the tools available to us now, not the ones we relied on when we started.”
That might mean:
- Using Photoshop to adjust contrast and brightness—with documented settings
- Retaining original images with metadata intact
- Adding screenshots or step-by-step visual logs of enhancements
- Clearly identifying the basis for any exclusions or identifications
Not only does this enhance transparency—it reduces ambiguity for supervisors, peer reviewers, and external forensic consultants.
If you haven’t updated your documentation workflows recently, here’s your nudge to start.
4 Actionable Tips to Improve Your Forensic Case Reports Today
Ready to level up your documentation? Start with these steps:
1. Audit Your SOPs
- When was the last time your SOPs were revised?
- Are they aligned with current OSAC standards?
2. Implement Metadata Preservation Policies
- Save original images with intact metadata
- Use image enhancement tools responsibly and document each step
3. Include Annotated Screenshots
- Highlight key features directly on the image
- Reference image IDs in your notes to eliminate ambiguity
4. Train Your Team on Cognitive Bias Awareness
- Discuss examples of confirmation bias in team meetings
- Encourage peer review with opposing views
Forensic Supervisors: Lead the Change Before You’re Forced To
A message to forensic supervisors: your influence goes far beyond your own documentation. You’re shaping the standards and setting the tone of your entire team.
And let’s be real. If your SOPs haven’t been updated since the 2010s (or earlier!), now’s the time to course correct. If your reports are thorough and up-to-date, your team will follow suit. If you’re still clinging to “the old way,” they will too.
John had a powerful message for supervisors: Lead the change, don’t wait for it.
Here’s What Forensic Supervisors Can Do:
✅ Run a documentation audit: Pick a few random cases and assess them for consistency, clarity, and completeness.
✅ Implement peer reviews: Encourage collaborative feedback, not punitive corrections.
✅ Host a “standards refresher” workshop: Brief your team on current forensic case report best practices and invite open discussion.
If you’re worried that improving documentation will slow your team down, consider the cost of being unprepared during a legal challenge. The risk isn’t just professional—it could impact your cases.
“It’s not about protecting yourself from consultants. It’s about doing the best science you can.” — Podcast Host
Bonus: Advice for Introverted Forensic Leaders
During our episode, John also spoke on a lesser-discussed topic: the challenge of being an introverted forensic professional in a leadership role.
If you’re someone who gets nervous speaking in public, dislikes confrontation, or avoids the spotlight—this one’s for you.
John’s advice:
- Embrace preparation: Confidence often comes from being well-prepared.
- Use documentation as a leadership tool: Let your writing and organization speak volumes.
- Don’t try to be someone you’re not: Quiet, thoughtful leadership is just as powerful as charismatic leadership.
(And if this topic resonates with you, be sure to catch John’s full session from our Forensic Supervisor Success Summit, titled Intorvert’s Guide to Conquer Public Speaking.)
Final Thoughts: Build Case Files You’d Be Proud to Defend
Every forensic professional will eventually have their work questioned. That’s not a threat—it’s a reality. But if you consistently follow forensic case report best practices, you can face that scrutiny with confidence.
Improving your reports doesn’t require a total overhaul. It’s about making small, intentional improvements—every day, every case.
Because at the end of the day:
- Your reports protect your reputation.
- They support your testimony.
- They guide peer review.
And when consultants like John Black pick up your case file, your goal should be for them to say: “This one doesn’t need me. They nailed it.”
Unlimited Access to Leadership Training for Forensic Supervisors
If you want to learn from John Black and other forensic leadership experts, get access to the 2023 Forensic Supervisor Success Summit Replay.
With the All-Access Pass, you’ll gain immediate access to John’s presentation, “Introvert’s Guide to Conquer Public Speaking,” along with 27 other expert-led sessions covering forensic supervision, leadership strategies, and unit efficiency. Don’t miss out—secure your access today!
👉 Purchase the full replay here
Don’t miss this opportunity to enhance your leadership skills, improve forensic unit operations, and gain insights from top forensic professionals!
Keep Learning: More Insights from Forensic Leadership Experts
If you’re eager to continue exploring forensic leadership, check out these podcast episodes featuring summit speakers:
- Knowing When It’s Time to Walk Away with Alice White from Evolve Forensics
- A CSI’s Story: When Crime Scene Investigations Turn Dangerous with Letty Ramirez
- How Kat Pope Became Alcohol-Free and Developed a Better Way to Handle Work-Related Stress with Kat Pope from Forensics Found
